Jurors’ Questions in Karen Read Retrial Signal Potential Good News for Defense
Experts say jurors’ questions in Karen Read’s retrial suggest they may be considering lesser charges than murder in the case of her boyfriend John O’Keefe’s death. The first set of jurors’ questions sent back to the court in Karen Read’s retrial could be a positive sign for her defense – at least as it pertains to the most serious charge she faces, experts say.
Judge Beverly Cannone read the three questions in court around 11 a.m. Tuesday. ‘No doubt the defense is elated,’ said Jack Lu, a retired Massachusetts judge and Boston College law professor.
Questions one and three are favorable for the defense, Lu told Fox News Digital, while two is ‘neutral.’ All three indicate jurors are considering a lesser included charge rather than the top count of first-degree murder.
Read is accused of killing her then-boyfriend John O’Keefe in a drunken hit-and-run on Jan. 29, 2022, outside a party in Canton, Massachusetts. The retrial follows her first trial, which ended in a hung jury last year after jurors went more than 25 hours over four days without reaching an agreement.
Mark Bederow, a New York City-based defense attorney who represents Read’s ally and Canton blogger Aidan Kearney, said the questions would have been addressed if the defense motion for an amended jury slip wasn’t rejected Monday. ‘It does appear that the jury is entirely focused on OUI based on all three questions,’ he said. ‘This encapsulates the problem with the count 2 slip and appears to be a repeat of what happened at the first trial – when a confused jury seemingly acquitted on all homicide charges and got confused with the convoluted instructions on the count 2 lessers.’
Read’s blood-alcohol level was estimated to be around 0.09% when she was hospitalized for a mental health check following the discovery of O’Keefe’s remains. Nine hours earlier, at the time of his death, it was estimated to be significantly higher, although the defense argued she could have continued to drink after returning home.
‘That tells me they are focusing on how alcohol played a role in this case, which is what the last jury found important also,’ said Grace Edwards, a Massachusetts defense attorney who is following the case. Read faces up to life in prison if convicted on the most serious charge of second-degree murder. Some of the OUI-related charges also carry multi-year penalties, Edwards said.