Urban Meyer, the former head coach of the University of Florida and Ohio State, joined Colin Cowherd on The Herd to weigh in on a trio of controversial early-season developments in college football. The discussion centered on three topics: the ongoing debate around Arch Manning’s potential, the shocking loss of the Alabama Crimson Tide on opening night, and Bill Belichick’s unexpected defeat against TCU in his first coaching appearance.
Meyer, known for his sharp insights into football strategy and program management, expressed skepticism toward the immediate reaction to Arch Manning’s performance. While acknowledging the quarterback’s high-profile status, he emphasized the need for context, pointing out that the young player’s first season would involve a steep learning curve. Critics, however, have been quick to blame Manning’s coaching staff for any perceived deficiencies in his play.
The Alabama loss dominated the conversation, with Meyer calling it one of the most surprising results of the season. The Crimson Tide, a perennial powerhouse, suffered their first defeat of the year on opening day, raising questions about their readiness for the challenges ahead. Meyer noted that while such a loss was shocking, it may also indicate that teams are finally starting to find ways to challenge the traditionally dominant Tide program.
Bill Belichick’s debut as a coach, albeit for the University of North Carolina, also drew significant attention. His team’s loss to TCU was described as “shocking” by Cowherd and Meyer, sparking discussions about whether Belichick’s hiring was a misstep or if the team was simply underprepared. Meyer, while offering no clear verdict, suggested that Belichick’s experience might eventually translate into success, though it could take time to see the full impact.
As the season progresses, the focus remains on these pivotal moments and how they shape the narratives around these programs. Meyer’s comments add another layer to the ongoing debate, reminding fans that early-season setbacks can be part of a larger story rather than isolated incidents.