On October 9, 2025, President Donald Trump’s Cabinet erupted in applause as he signed a proclamation officially celebrating Columbus Day. The event marked the return of the holiday to its original date, which had been moved to the second Monday in October in 2024. Trump’s remarks, including his statement, ‘We’re back, Italians,’ sparked debate over the historical narrative surrounding Columbus’ legacy and its place in American commemorations.
The proclamation, which Trump presented as a reaffirmation of American values and historical tradition, was met with both praise and criticism. Supporters argued that the decision to revert to the original date honored the legacy of Columbus, while critics highlighted the controversy surrounding his role in the colonization of the Americas. The move also reignited discussions about the broader implications of American holidays and their connection to colonial history.
Trump’s Cabinet, which had previously expressed support for the 2024 change, seemed to have shifted its stance, aligning with the President’s decision to reclaim the original date. The administration’s rationale for the change was based on the idea that the original date, October 12, is more reflective of the intended significance of the holiday. However, the decision has drawn attention to the complex legacy of Columbus, with many advocating for a more inclusive and critical approach to teaching history in schools.