Review: ‘Wicked: For Good’ Struggles With Tonal Shift and Structural Flaws
Fox News Digital’s review of *Wicked: For Good* praises the film’s technical execution but criticizes its divisive approach to storytelling. The sequel, following the box office success of the first film, attempts to explore darker themes of political resistance and moral conflict, but its disjointed narrative and tonal contrast to the lighthearted predecessor have sparked debate among audiences.
Directed by Jon M. Chu, the film reteams Cynthia Erivo and Ariana Grande as Elphaba and Glinda, with Jonathan Bailey, Michelle Yeoh, and Jeff Goldblum reprising their roles. While Erivo’s performance as the rebellious witch remains strong, Grande’s portrayal of Glinda’s internal struggle for allegiance adds depth to her character arc. The review commends Chu’s visual flair, noting the film’s lavish costumes and effects, but questions whether the structural split of the musical was worth the compromise in storytelling.
Universal Pictures’ decision to divide the original stage musical into two films has drawn criticism, particularly after the first film’s $750 million global run. The review argues that the second film’s heavier tone and limited musical highlights—a contrast to the first film’s iconic songs like ‘Defying Gravity’—undermine its appeal. While Stephen Schwartz’s new compositions provide some relief, the absence of the original stage musical’s most memorable tracks leaves the sequel feeling incomplete.
The film’s PG rating and attempt to balance dark themes with family-friendly content are also questioned, as the second act’s moral complexity clashes with the film’s need to appeal to younger audiences. Despite these flaws, the review acknowledges the film’s artistic merit and visual spectacle, though it ultimately concludes that *For Good* is a ‘good but not great’ conclusion to the *Wicked* saga. The film opens in theaters in November 2025, with critics urging studios to reconsider splitting musicals into two parts in the future.