Major League Baseball Commissioner Rob Manfred Urged to Avoid the Obvious in Handling the Cleveland Guardians Pitchers’ Gambling Case
Major League Baseball Commissioner Rob Manfred faces a pivotal decision regarding the punishment of Cleveland Guardians pitchers Emmanuel Clase and Luis Ortiz, who have been indicted for gambling violations involving the intentional, illegal throwing of pitches. The issue has gained significant attention as fans and analysts urge Manfred to avoid the seemingly obvious but potentially harsh punishment of a lifetime ban. Instead, the call is to show mercy and justice, a choice that could have profound implications not only for the players but also for the league’s reputation.
Clase and Ortiz, both from the Dominican Republic, are accused of rigging individual pitches to benefit gamblers, with allegations of potentially earning around $400,000 through what are known as ‘prop bets.’ They are facing federal charges of wire fraud and conspiracy. While the possibility of prison time is present, it is unlikely given their status as alleged first-time offenders in a non-violent crime. However, the decision Manfred makes regarding their punishment will determine the future of their careers and the impact on the league’s integrity.
Manfred’s previous decision to move the 2021 All-Star Game from Atlanta due to political pressures has left a mark on his reputation. The move, driven by Georgia’s controversial voting law, was seen by many as a capitulation to left-wing activism, a move that failed to gain widespread approval. Despite the initial backlash, the league has since corrected this decision by awarding Atlanta the All-Star Game in 2023. Now, the commissioner has an opportunity to rectify this by making a judgment call that balances justice with mercy.
The article argues that the players are not engaging in high-level, sophisticated cheating, but rather in an arguably reckless and easily detectable form of misconduct. Despite the sophistication of the gambling industry’s oversight, the act of intentionally throwing bad pitches is a clear violation of the sport’s integrity. However, the call for a lifetime ban is seen as disproportionate, particularly given the players’ origins in the Dominican Republic, where baseball is a central aspect of life and the players’ educational systems may not offer the same level of oversight as in more developed countries.
Instead of a lifetime ban, the article proposes a more proportionate punishment, offering an alternative that would include a portion of their salaries being directed to charitable causes while the players are in the league. This approach aims to send a strong message about the importance of integrity in sports without completely ruining the players’ careers. The piece also references a Shakespearean call for mercy, emphasizing the value of compassion in the face of wrongdoing.
Ultimately, the decision Manfred makes will not only impact Clase and Ortiz but also set a precedent for how the league addresses similar issues in the future. As the commissioner faces this critical juncture, the piece encourages him to demonstrate leadership by choosing a course that is both fair and thoughtful, ensuring that the league maintains its integrity while also showing the players the value of a balanced approach to accountability and mercy.
Hugh Hewitt is host of