The Southeastern Conference (SEC) has acknowledged a significant officiating error during Oklahoma’s 24-17 victory over Auburn in their recent matchup, with the conference calling the disputed touchdown play unsportsmanlike conduct. The ruling, which came after a thorough review of the game footage, affirmed that the play should have been penalized, leading to a 15-yard penalty from the previous spot. Auburn head coach Hugh Freeze, who had publicly criticized the officiating during the game, was vindicated in this instance, as the SEC’s decision aligned with his team’s position.
The controversial call occurred in the second quarter when Oklahoma’s Isaiah Sategna III executed what appeared to be a substitution, running toward the sideline before abruptly stopping near the boundary. The Auburn defense believed he had officially exited the game and was not part of the offense when the ball was snapped, leading to a touchdown. The SEC’s review confirmed the play was classified as a hideout tactic, which is explicitly prohibited under NCAA Rule 9-2, Article 2. This rule prohibits any simulated replacements or substitutions designed to confuse opponents, and the SEC emphasized that the play should have been called for unsportsman, with a penalty assessed. Freeze, who had warned his staff all offseason about such plays being illegal, agreed with the official ruling after the game.
Freeze’s postgame comments were laced with frustration, particularly regarding multiple calls that went against Auburn. He also expressed skepticism about the ruling on the second touchdown, which he argued was a legitimate fumble. The situation highlights the intense scrutiny placed on referees in collegiate football, as well as the high stakes of close games. The ruling by the SEC has sparked discussions about the need for better officiating training and clearer application of rules, especially in complex and deceptive plays. As the college football season progresses, such controversies are likely to continue, testing the integrity of the sport and the ability of officials to enforce regulations effectively.