Costco’s iconic Kirkland Signature Pumpkin Pie has made a triumphant return to stores across the country, capturing the hearts of holiday shoppers with its unbeatable value. This year’s offering, priced at $5.99, has remained unchanged since its debut, a rarity in an era of inflation and rising costs. The pie, which weighs a hefty 58 ounces or nearly four pounds, is a staple of Thanksgiving gatherings and holiday celebrations, with many fans claiming they’ve never found a better deal on such a rich dessert.
The pie’s massive size has sparked a mix of reactions online, with some shoppers praising its generous portions while others find it overwhelming for smaller households. On social media platforms like TikTok and Reddit, users have shared creative ways to make the most of the oversized dessert, from freezing slices for later enjoyment to combining portions with other treats for unique flavor combinations. One popular tip involves slicing the pie and freezing individual pieces in airtight containers, ensuring the pie remains fresh for weeks beyond the traditional pumpkin season.
Despite its size, the pie has received rave reviews for its quality and taste. Food influencers like Sarah Margaret Sandlin of @SarahMargaretEats have taken to social media to showcase their experiences with the pie, with Sandlin and her mother enjoying the dessert in the Costco parking lot. Their video of the first bite went viral, highlighting the pie’s creamy texture and rich flavor. The pie’s recipe, which includes pumpkin, sugar, and eggs in a flaky crust, has become a benchmark for homemade pumpkin pies, leading to many online discussions about how to recreate the Costco version at home.
Costco’s pumpkin pie season typically runs from late August through December, with the pie available in the bakery section near other holiday treats like apple pie and pastries. While the pie remains a popular choice, some shoppers have expressed a desire for smaller servings, particularly for those living alone. Suggestions for alternative uses for the pie pan have also emerged, with one Redditor joking about repurposing it as a manhole cover or snow sled. Despite these minor gripes, the overwhelming sentiment among shoppers is one of appreciation for the pie’s affordability and deliciousness.
As the holiday season approaches, the Kirkland Signature Pumpkin Pie continues to be a symbol of Costco’s commitment to offering high-quality products at unbeatable prices. With its return, the pie has once again become a must-have item for families and foodies alike, proving that sometimes the best deals are the ones that never change.